Lesson 1

Which law applies: the provincial map

Video
2 min
Reading
10 min
Exercise
8 min
Total
20 min

Educational content, not legal advice.

In this lesson you will

  1. Place each activity under the federal law, a provincial private sector law, a health statute or a public sector law.
  2. Recognise a health custodian in Ontario, Alberta and Nova Scotia, and spot the non-profit and public body exclusions.
  3. Explain why one organization can work under several regimes at once.

Video lesson

Length: 1:33
Read the transcript

This is lesson one of Provincial and Health Privacy Laws: which law applies. We follow Brackwater Health Group, our fictional clinic group, with clinics in Vancouver, Calgary, Toronto and Halifax.

The federal private sector law covers commercial activity and information that crosses borders PIPEDA s.4(1), s.26(2)(b); SOR/2003-374; SOR/2004-219; SOR/2004-220; SOR/2005-399; SOR/2011-265; SI/2012-72; SOR/2016-62, but staff files only in federal works, undertakings and businesses. PIPEDA s.4(1)(b) It steps back within British Columbia and Alberta, and for health custodians within Ontario and Nova Scotia. PIPEDA s.4(1), s.26(2)(b); SOR/2003-374; SOR/2004-219; SOR/2004-220; SOR/2005-399; SOR/2011-265; SI/2012-72; SOR/2016-62

In Toronto and Halifax, the health statutes attach to custodians, such as the operator of a group practice of regulated professionals. PHIPA s.3(1) para. 1; s.2 "health care practitioner" (a); s.3(3) para. 1 NS PHIA s.3(f) In Alberta, a health services provider is a custodian only if the regulations designate it. AB HIA s.1(1)(f)

The provincial private sector laws cover the Vancouver and Calgary staff files and the app's sign ups within each province. PIPEDA s.26(2)(b); SOR/2003-374; SOR/2004-219; SOR/2004-220; SOR/2005-399; SOR/2011-265; SI/2012-72; SOR/2016-62; OPC, Provincial laws that may apply instead of PIPEDA

Working for a BC health authority brings in the public sector law, and the private sector law steps aside for that information. BC PIPA s.3(2)(d) A charity's newsletter list is outside Alberta's private sector law, unless the list is sold, bartered or leased. AB PIPA s.56(1)-(3)

Recap: map activities, not the organization, and name the law for each one. Next: collecting and using information in British Columbia and Alberta.

Notes

The first question people get wrong

Outside Quebec, the question is rarely whether a privacy law applies. It is which one. A single organization can answer to the federal private sector law, two provincial private sector laws, three health statutes and a public sector law in the same week. This lesson builds the map one activity at a time, so each later lesson starts from the right law.

Meet Brackwater

Brackwater Health Group Inc. is a fictional group of physiotherapy and family medicine clinics in Vancouver, Calgary, Toronto and Halifax. A head office team runs payroll, marketing and a booking app used in all four cities. Brackwater has just signed a contract to run a physiotherapy program for a British Columbia health authority, and it supports a small charity in Calgary that raises funds for patients who cannot pay.

Start with the federal law, and its limits

The federal private sector law applies to personal information handled in the course of commercial activity, to employee and job applicant information of federal works, undertakings and businesses, and to personal information that crosses provincial or national borders in the course of commercial activity. PIPEDA s.4(1), s.26(2)(b); SOR/2003-374; SOR/2004-219; SOR/2004-220; SOR/2005-399; SOR/2011-265; SI/2012-72; SOR/2016-62 For employees, it applies only where the information is handled in connection with a federal work, undertaking or business. PIPEDA s.4(1)(b) Brackwater runs clinics, not a bank or an airline, so the federal law does not reach its staff files.

Then come the exemptions. Organizations subject to the Alberta or British Columbia private sector laws are exempt for activity within that province, and health information custodians are exempt for activity within Ontario, New Brunswick, Newfoundland and Labrador or Nova Scotia. PIPEDA s.4(1), s.26(2)(b); SOR/2003-374; SOR/2004-219; SOR/2004-220; SOR/2005-399; SOR/2011-265; SI/2012-72; SOR/2016-62 The federal law still applies in Alberta and British Columbia to personal information transferred across borders. PIPEDA s.26(2)(b); SOR/2003-374; SOR/2004-219; SOR/2004-220; SOR/2005-399; SOR/2011-265; SI/2012-72; SOR/2016-62; OPC, Provincial laws that may apply instead of PIPEDA

The health statutes: who is a custodian

The health statutes attach to custodians, so the first step is to find them.

In Ontario, a health information custodian includes a health care practitioner, or a person who operates a group practice of health care practitioners, who has custody or control of personal health information as a result of or in connection with that work. PHIPA s.3(1) para. 1; s.2 "health care practitioner" (a); s.3(3) para. 1 A member of a College under the Regulated Health Professions Act, 1991 who provides health care is a health care practitioner. PHIPA s.3(1) para. 1; s.2 "health care practitioner" (a); s.3(3) para. 1 A practitioner who acts as the agent of another custodian is not a custodian for the information handled in that role. PHIPA s.3(1) para. 1; s.2 "health care practitioner" (a); s.3(3) para. 1 So in Toronto the custodian is usually Brackwater as the operator of the group practice, and the physiotherapists it employs handle records as its agents.

In Nova Scotia, a custodian has custody or control of personal health information in connection with its powers or duties and is one of a listed group, which includes a regulated health professional and a person who operates a group practice of them. NS PHIA s.3(f)

Alberta works differently. Its list of custodians names hospital operators, licensed pharmacies, health authorities and similar bodies, and a health services provider is a custodian only if the regulations designate it, or its class, that way. AB HIA s.1(1)(f) In Alberta, regulated members of the designated health profession colleges are custodians, including physicians and, since June 22, 2026, physiotherapists. Health Information (Ministerial) Regulation, Alta Reg 106/2026, ss.1, 7, 9; HIA s.1(1)(a), (f)(ix), (3), (3.1)(a) Each of them is a custodian, and a company that performs a service for them under a contract, like Brackwater, which runs the Calgary clinic and its booking app, is their affiliate. Health Information (Ministerial) Regulation, Alta Reg 106/2026, ss.1, 7, 9; HIA s.1(1)(a), (f)(ix), (3), (3.1)(a) A clinician who works as the affiliate of another custodian, such as a hospital operator, is not a custodian in that role. Health Information (Ministerial) Regulation, Alta Reg 106/2026, ss.1, 7, 9; HIA s.1(1)(a), (f)(ix), (3), (3.1)(a) Where the Alberta health statute applies to health information, Alberta's private sector law does not. AB PIPA s.4(2), s.4(3)(f)

The provincial private sector laws

British Columbia and Alberta each have a private sector law that the federal law steps back from within the province. PIPEDA s.26(2)(b); SOR/2003-374; SOR/2004-219; SOR/2004-220; SOR/2005-399; SOR/2011-265; SI/2012-72; SOR/2016-62; OPC, Provincial laws that may apply instead of PIPEDA They cover the head office's Vancouver and Calgary staff files, the booking app's sign ups within each province, and any clinic record that a health statute does not cover. Lessons 2 and 3 work through them.

Public bodies and non-profits

When Brackwater works for the BC health authority, a public sector law enters. British Columbia's public sector law applies to public bodies, which include local public bodies such as health care bodies. BC FIPPA s.1 ("public body", "local public body") The private sector law does not apply to personal information that the public sector law applies to. BC PIPA s.3(2)(d) In Alberta, the private sector law does not apply to a public body or to personal information in its custody or under its control. AB PIPA s.4(2), s.4(3)(f) Lesson 6 covers what the public body's law asks of a contractor.

Alberta's private sector law does not apply to a non-profit organization such as a society, except for personal information it handles in connection with a commercial activity, such as selling, bartering or leasing a donor or membership list. AB PIPA s.56(1)-(3) The federal law takes a similar line: non-profit status does not exempt an organization, but fundraising and mailing newsletters are generally not commercial activities, while selling a donor list is. PIPEDA s.2(1) "commercial activity", s.4(1)(a); OPC, How PIPEDA applies to charitable and non-profit organizations

One organization, many regimes

The map is not a list of laws that apply to Brackwater. It is a list of activities, each with its law. The template for this lesson is that map: one row per activity, with the province, the kind of information, the law, and the fact that decides it.

Worked example

Brackwater's which law map

Fictional organization. Brackwater Health Group Inc. is invented for this course. Any resemblance to a real organization is a coincidence.

The privacy lead built the map on one page, one row per activity, before writing any policy.

ActivityWhereLawWhy
Patient records at the Toronto clinicOntarioOntario health statuteBrackwater operates a group practice of College members PHIPA s.3(1) para. 1; s.2 "health care practitioner" (a); s.3(3) para. 1
Patient records at the Halifax clinicNova ScotiaNova Scotia health statuteGroup practice of regulated health professionals NS PHIA s.3(f)
Patient records at the Calgary clinicAlbertaThe Alberta health statute: each physician and physiotherapist is a custodian, and Brackwater is their affiliate Health Information (Ministerial) Regulation, Alta Reg 106/2026, ss.1, 7, 9; HIA s.1(1)(a), (f)(ix), (3), (3.1)(a) AB PIPA s.4(2), s.4(3)(f)Designation checked for each kind of clinician: both are designated Health Information (Ministerial) Regulation, Alta Reg 106/2026, ss.1, 7, 9; HIA s.1(1)(a), (f)(ix), (3), (3.1)(a)
Staff files, Vancouver and CalgaryBC, AlbertaEach province's private sector law PIPEDA s.26(2)(b); SOR/2003-374; SOR/2004-219; SOR/2004-220; SOR/2005-399; SOR/2011-265; SI/2012-72; SOR/2016-62; OPC, Provincial laws that may apply instead of PIPEDAThe federal law reaches staff files only in federal works PIPEDA s.4(1)(b)
Booking app data sent between provincesAll fourFederal private sector law PIPEDA s.4(1), s.26(2)(b); SOR/2003-374; SOR/2004-219; SOR/2004-220; SOR/2005-399; SOR/2011-265; SI/2012-72; SOR/2016-62Commercial activity across borders PIPEDA s.26(2)(b); SOR/2003-374; SOR/2004-219; SOR/2004-220; SOR/2005-399; SOR/2011-265; SI/2012-72; SOR/2016-62; OPC, Provincial laws that may apply instead of PIPEDA
Physiotherapy program for the BC health authorityBCBC public sector law, through the contract BC FIPPA s.1 ("public body", "local public body") BC PIPA s.3(2)(d)The authority is a public body BC FIPPA s.1 ("public body", "local public body")
The Calgary charity's donor newsletterAlbertaOutside Alberta's private sector law AB PIPA s.56(1)-(3)A society, and the list is not sold AB PIPA s.56(1)-(3)

What the map changed. The first draft policy said "Brackwater complies with PIPEDA." The map showed that the federal law covers one row of seven. The policy now has one section per row, each naming its law.

The Calgary row. It was marked "to confirm" until the designation check was written down; the check came back yes for both kinds of clinician, and the map records the date of the check. A map that guesses is worse than one that says what it does not yet know.

Scenario exercise · Allow 8 min

Map four new activities

Brackwater plans four changes. For each, name the law that applies and the fact that decides it:

  1. The Halifax clinic adds a family physician who is a regulated health professional.
  2. The Calgary charity, a society, wants to lease its donor list to another charity for a fee.
  3. Head office hires a payroll clerk in Toronto.
  4. The booking app starts sending Vancouver patients' booking data to the Toronto office for scheduling.
Show the model answer
  1. Nova Scotia health statute. Brackwater operates a group practice of regulated health professionals in Halifax, so it is a custodian there. NS PHIA s.3(f)
  2. Alberta's private sector law. Leasing a donor list is a commercial activity, so the non-profit exclusion no longer covers it. AB PIPA s.56(1)-(3)
  3. Not the federal law. The federal law reaches employee information only in a federal work, undertaking or business. PIPEDA s.4(1)(b) Brackwater notes on the map that no private sector law in this course covers that file, and handles it to the same standard as its other staff files.
  4. The federal private sector law. The data now crosses a provincial border in the course of commercial activity, and the federal law still applies to that in British Columbia. PIPEDA s.4(1), s.26(2)(b); SOR/2003-374; SOR/2004-219; SOR/2004-220; SOR/2005-399; SOR/2011-265; SI/2012-72; SOR/2016-62 PIPEDA s.26(2)(b); SOR/2003-374; SOR/2004-219; SOR/2004-220; SOR/2005-399; SOR/2011-265; SI/2012-72; SOR/2016-62; OPC, Provincial laws that may apply instead of PIPEDA

Why this is the strongest answer

Each answer starts from the activity, then asks who holds the information, where, and for what. The exclusions matter as much as the scope rules: a non-profit's list, a public body's records and a custodian's records within its province each move the answer. AB PIPA s.56(1)-(3) BC PIPA s.3(2)(d) PIPEDA s.4(1), s.26(2)(b); SOR/2003-374; SOR/2004-219; SOR/2004-220; SOR/2005-399; SOR/2011-265; SI/2012-72; SOR/2016-62

Template to download

Which law map (activity by activity)

One row per activity, with the province, the kind of information, the law that applies and the fact that decides it, plus checks for custodians, public bodies and non-profits.

Check your understanding

Scenario questions. Answer them all, then check: you will see why each option is right or wrong.

Question 1 of 5

A clinic group sends booking data from Vancouver to its Toronto office. Which law covers the transfer?

Question 2 of 5

A physiotherapist employed by an Ontario group practice handles patient records. Is the physiotherapist the custodian of them?

Question 3 of 5

What should a Calgary clinic check before treating its records as health information under the Alberta statute?

Question 4 of 5

A Calgary society that raises funds for patients mails a newsletter to its donors. What is true?

Question 5 of 5

Why does a which law map list activities rather than one law for the whole organization?

Sources cited in this lesson

  1. PIPEDA s.4(1), s.26(2)(b); SOR/2003-374; SOR/2004-219; SOR/2004-220; SOR/2005-399; SOR/2011-265; SI/2012-72; SOR/2016-62 official text current to 2026-09-30, checked on 2026-11-01
  2. PIPEDA s.4(1)(b) official text current to 2026-09-30, checked on 2026-10-24
  3. PIPEDA s.26(2)(b); SOR/2003-374; SOR/2004-219; SOR/2004-220; SOR/2005-399; SOR/2011-265; SI/2012-72; SOR/2016-62; OPC, Provincial laws that may apply instead of PIPEDA official text current to 2020-05-11, checked on 2026-10-29
  4. PHIPA s.3(1) para. 1; s.2 "health care practitioner" (a); s.3(3) para. 1 official text current to 2026-10-28, checked on 2026-11-02
  5. NS PHIA s.3(f) official text current to 2026-04-01, checked on 2026-11-02
  6. AB HIA s.1(1)(f) official text current to 2026-07-02, checked on 2026-11-02
  7. Health Information (Ministerial) Regulation, Alta Reg 106/2026, ss.1, 7, 9; HIA s.1(1)(a), (f)(ix), (3), (3.1)(a) official text current to 2026-07-02, checked on 2026-11-03
  8. AB PIPA s.4(2), s.4(3)(f) official text current to 2025-09-01, checked on 2026-10-26
  9. BC FIPPA s.1 ("public body", "local public body") official text current to 2026-10-20, checked on 2026-10-26
  10. BC PIPA s.3(2)(d) official text current to 2026-10-20, checked on 2026-10-26
  11. AB PIPA s.56(1)-(3) official text current to 2025-09-01, checked on 2026-10-26
  12. PIPEDA s.2(1) "commercial activity", s.4(1)(a); OPC, How PIPEDA applies to charitable and non-profit organizations checked on 2026-10-26

Get the full course

One payment of 59 USD. Every lesson, the knowledge checks, the final exam and the certificate open on your account. The first lesson is free to read.

Prices are in US dollars. Terms of sale · Privacy notice

You can ask for a full refund of a course within 14 days of buying it, if you have not passed its final exam.