When a PIA is required, and when it is simply wise
- Video
- 3 min
- Reading
- 10 min
- Exercise
- 6 min
- Total
- 18 min
Educational content, not legal advice.
In this lesson you will
- Decide whether a project calls for a privacy impact assessment under Quebec law.
- Recognise the other Quebec triggers: communication outside Quebec and research access without consent.
- Explain the position under the federal private sector law, and what a federal bill proposes for transfers.
Video lesson
Read the transcript
Welcome to Valdra Academy. This is lesson one of Privacy Impact Assessment in Practice. By the end of this course you will have run a complete assessment, and this lesson starts with the first question every project asks: do we need one?
In Quebec, often the answer is yes. An enterprise conducts a privacy impact assessment for any project to acquire, develop or overhaul an information system or electronic service delivery system involving personal information. P-39.1 s.3.3 Acquiring a system counts, not only building one. So does an overhaul.
Sensitivity sets the depth, not whether one is needed. P-39.1 s.3.3, s.17 The assessment is proportionate to the sensitivity of the information, its purposes, its quantity and distribution, and where it is stored. P-39.1 s.3.3 And the person in charge of the protection of personal information is consulted from the outset. P-39.1 s.3.3
There are other triggers. Before communicating personal information outside Quebec, an enterprise conducts an assessment and signs a written agreement. P-39.1 s.8 para 2, s.17 Sharing identifiable information for research without consent also needs an assessment first. P-39.1 ss.21, 21.0.1, 21.0.2
Elsewhere in Canada, the federal private sector law does not require one, and the Commissioner recommends one as good practice. PIPEDA (no PIA provision) OPC, OIPC Alberta and OIPC British Columbia, Getting Accountability Right with a Privacy Management Program (April 2012), Part A, Risk assessment tools Bill C-36 proposes an assessment before transfers outside Canada, but it is not law. Bill C-36 s.57
Our fictional gym chain, Brisewood Fitness, is about to launch a member app. It has gyms in Montreal, Gatineau and Ottawa, a booking feature, location check in, fingerprint entry at two sites and a customer system hosted in the United States. Run it through four screening questions and every answer is yes.
Recap: in Quebec, a system project with personal information needs an assessment, and so does a transfer outside Quebec. Elsewhere it is good practice. Next: scoping the project and mapping the data.
What a privacy impact assessment is for
A privacy impact assessment, or PIA, is a structured look at a project before it goes live: what personal information it will touch, what could go wrong for the people concerned, and what the organization will do about it. Done early, it is cheap. Done after launch, it becomes a list of things to rebuild.
This course follows one project from start to finish and builds its PIA file one lesson at a time. This first lesson answers the question every project lead asks first: do we actually need one?
Quebec: a PIA for every information system project
In Quebec the answer is often yes, by law. An enterprise conducts a privacy impact assessment for any project to acquire, develop or overhaul an information system or electronic service delivery system involving the collection, use, communication, keeping or destruction of personal information. P-39.1 s.3.3
Three parts of that rule decide most cases.
- Acquire, develop or overhaul. The rule covers acquiring a system as well as developing one, and overhauling an existing one. P-39.1 s.3.3 Read "acquire" broadly: buying or subscribing to a software service is the usual way a system arrives today.
- Information system or electronic service delivery system. A client portal, a mobile app, a CRM, a payroll platform, an online booking tool. P-39.1 s.3.3
- Involving personal information. Any of collection, use, communication, keeping or destruction is enough. P-39.1 s.3.3
Sensitivity changes how deep the assessment goes, not whether one is needed. P-39.1 s.3.3, s.17 The assessment is proportionate to the sensitivity of the information, the purposes for which it is used, its quantity and distribution and the medium on which it is stored. P-39.1 s.3.3 A small booking tool with names and phone numbers gets a short PIA. A health app gets a long one.
The person in charge of the protection of personal information is consulted from the outset of the project, not at the end. P-39.1 s.3.3 In Quebec that role belongs by default to the person with the highest authority in the enterprise, who can delegate it in writing. P-39.1 s.3.1
Quebec: the other triggers
The project trigger is not the only one.
- Communicating personal information outside Quebec. Before an enterprise communicates personal information outside Quebec, it conducts a privacy impact assessment and signs a written agreement. P-39.1 s.8 para 2, s.17 The same applies when it entrusts a person or body outside Quebec with collecting, using, communicating or keeping the information on its behalf, such as a cloud provider. P-39.1 s.17 Lesson 5 covers this assessment in detail.
- Research and statistics without consent. An enterprise may communicate personal information without consent for study, research or statistics only if a privacy impact assessment concludes, among other things, that the objective can be achieved only with identifiable information and that it is unreasonable to require consent. P-39.1 ss.21, 21.0.1, 21.0.2
The rest of Canada: recommended, not imposed
The federal private sector law does not require a privacy impact assessment, and the federal Privacy Commissioner recommends one as good practice. PIPEDA (no PIA provision) OPC, OIPC Alberta and OIPC British Columbia, Getting Accountability Right with a Privacy Management Program (April 2012), Part A, Risk assessment tools A federal bill, Bill C-36, proposes that an organization carry out a privacy impact assessment before disclosing or transferring personal information outside Canada; it is a proposal, not law. Bill C-36 s.57
There are good reasons to run one anyway. An organization operating in Quebec and in other provinces usually runs one method everywhere rather than two. And a PIA is the easiest way to show, after the fact, that the organization thought about the risks before it acted.
Other regimes you may meet
Two short pointers, so the vocabulary does not surprise you:
- In the European Union, a controller carries out a data protection impact assessment before processing that is likely to result in a high risk to people's rights and freedoms, in particular when using new technologies. GDPR Art. 35(1), (3)(a)
- Public bodies in Ontario, British Columbia and Alberta have their own PIA rules under their public sector laws. ON FIPPA s.38(3)-(6) BC FIPPA s.69(1) ("privacy impact assessment"), (5), (5.1), (5.3), (5.4) AB Protection of Privacy Act s.25(1), s.26(1)-(3) This course is about private enterprises and does not cover them.
Screen every project the same way
The simplest habit is a one page screening form that every project fills in at kickoff. It asks four questions: is this a new or overhauled system, does it involve personal information, will any information leave Quebec, and is any information sensitive? A yes to the first two in Quebec means a PIA. A yes to the third means a transfer assessment as well. The fourth sets the depth. The template for this lesson is that form.
Screening the Brisewood member app
Fictional organization. Brisewood Fitness Inc. is invented for this course. Any resemblance to a real company is a coincidence.
Brisewood Fitness runs 14 gyms in Montreal, Gatineau and Ottawa. It is launching a member app that books classes, checks members in when they arrive near a gym, suggests workouts based on past visits, and opens the door by fingerprint at two pilot sites. Member data will sit in a CRM hosted by a provider in the United States.
At kickoff the project lead filled in the screening form with the privacy lead.
| Question | Answer | What follows |
|---|---|---|
| Is this a new or overhauled system? | Yes: a new app and a new CRM | A project PIA is needed in Quebec P-39.1 s.3.3 |
| Does it involve personal information? | Yes: identity, contact, attendance, location, fingerprints | Same P-39.1 s.3.3 |
| Will any information leave Quebec? | Yes: the CRM is hosted in the United States (and the Ottawa gyms use the same system) | A transfer assessment and a written agreement P-39.1 s.17 |
| Is any information sensitive? | Yes: fingerprints are biometric, and location reveals daily habits | The PIA goes deep P-39.1 s.3.3, s.17 |
What happened next. The project lead had planned to "do privacy" the month before launch. The screening form moved it to the start, booked the privacy lead into every design review, and set the PIA as a launch gate. The Ottawa gyms fall under the federal law, which does not require a PIA, but Brisewood decided to run one method for all 14 sites. PIPEDA (no PIA provision)
Screen four projects
You are the privacy lead at a Quebec retailer. Four requests land on your desk the same week:
- Marketing wants to replace the email newsletter tool with a new service that segments customers by purchase history.
- IT is moving the staff intranet's look and feel to a new theme. No data model changes.
- Finance will send the customer accounts receivable file to a collection agency in Ontario.
- A professor at a local university asks for identifiable purchase records for a study on spending habits.
For each one, say whether a PIA is needed under Quebec law, which trigger applies, and how deep the PIA should go.
Show the model answer
- PIA needed. Acquiring a new system that uses personal information. Medium depth: purchase history reveals habits, and segmentation is a new use.
- Probably no PIA. A visual theme is not an overhaul of how personal information is collected, used, kept or destroyed. Record the decision on the screening form.
- PIA needed, as a transfer assessment. Communicating personal information outside Quebec. The agreement with the agency follows from it. Medium depth: financial information.
- PIA needed before any data goes out. Research access without consent depends on an assessment that reaches the conclusions the law lists. P-39.1 ss.21, 21.0.1, 21.0.2 A written request from the researcher and an agreement sent to the Commission also come first; the agreement takes effect 30 days after the Commission receives it. P-39.1 ss.21, 21.0.1, 21.0.2 Deep: identifiable records, a third party, no consent.
Why this is the strongest answer
A system project involving personal information triggers a PIA in Quebec, whatever its sensitivity. P-39.1 s.3.3, s.17 A communication outside Quebec needs its own assessment and a written agreement. P-39.1 s.8 para 2, s.17 Research access without consent depends on an assessment's conclusions. P-39.1 ss.21, 21.0.1, 21.0.2 Writing down why a project did not need a PIA is a good habit that saves the argument later.
PIA trigger screening form
A one page form every project fills in at kickoff: four questions that tell you whether a PIA is needed in Quebec, whether a transfer assessment is needed, and how deep to go.
Check your understanding
Sources cited in this lesson
- P-39.1 s.3.3 official text current to 2026-10-15, checked on 2026-10-26
- P-39.1 s.3.3, s.17 official text current to 2026-10-15, checked on 2026-11-01
- P-39.1 s.3.1 official text current to 2026-10-15, checked on 2026-10-29
- P-39.1 s.8 para 2, s.17 official text current to 2026-10-15, checked on 2026-10-26
- P-39.1 s.17 official text current to 2026-10-15, checked on 2026-11-01
- P-39.1 ss.21, 21.0.1, 21.0.2 official text current to 2026-10-15, checked on 2026-10-29
- PIPEDA (no PIA provision) official text current to 2026-09-30, checked on 2026-10-24
- OPC, OIPC Alberta and OIPC British Columbia, Getting Accountability Right with a Privacy Management Program (April 2012), Part A, Risk assessment tools official text current to 2012-04-17, checked on 2026-11-02
- Bill C-36 s.57 checked on 2026-10-24
- GDPR Art. 35(1), (3)(a) official text current to 2016-05-04, checked on 2026-10-26
- ON FIPPA s.38(3)-(6) official text current to 2026-10-21, checked on 2026-10-26
- BC FIPPA s.69(1) ("privacy impact assessment"), (5), (5.1), (5.3), (5.4) official text current to 2026-10-20, checked on 2026-10-26
- AB Protection of Privacy Act s.25(1), s.26(1)-(3) official text current to 2025-12-11, checked on 2026-10-26
Get the full course
One payment of 59 USD. Every lesson, the knowledge checks, the final exam and the certificate open on your account. The first lesson is free to read.
Prices are in US dollars. Terms of sale · Privacy notice
You can ask for a full refund of a course within 14 days of buying it, if you have not passed its final exam.